Why Did You Doubt? [Proper 14A - Matthew 14:22-33]
The Rt. Rev. Jeremiah Williamson Matthew 14:22-33 Why Did You Doubt? St. Mary’s, Springfield Center As he thrashed around in the tumultuous sea, the answer to Jesus’ query seemed rather obvious. And the doubt in Peter’s mind justified. And yet, it was in that chaotic moment in which Jesus posed his question. Because, after all, who doesn’t enjoy a deep philosophical discussion when one is pre-occupied with drowning? Jesus asked Peter the “why” question. And I don’t know if that was advisable. As a parent, I can tell you, experts work very hard to talk that question out of the parental vocabulary. In books and blogs, they claim it causes shame or fear. Sometimes a cognitive block. Often defensiveness. In the Gospel text, Peter’s response to Jesus’ “why” is not recorded – if there even was one. It is difficult to talk when one is terrified and choking on water. Still in th...